I like to research regional specialties and where to eat before I visit. I cross-index my zagat's with the yelp reviews. I calibrate all reviews with the idea that they may be over-inflated. Here's the list of food that I looked for during my stay- 72 hours of eating: Clam chowder, Lobster roll, Oysters, Baked Beans, Boston Cream Pie, Brown Bread, Indian Pudding, Canoli, Italian, Soft-shelled Crab, Ice Cream, I include the bad restaurants in my list so you don't have to. If you have suggestions on where else to eat, I'll be back in October for a short time. So let me know and I'll be sure to add to the list.
1. Giacomo's
355 Hanover St
Boston, MA 02113
(617) 523-9026
Category: Italian
Neighborhoods: Charlestown, North End
5 star rating
Tightly packed tables are angled to maximize capacity NOT PRIVACY but still crowds of people must bravely wait 45 minutes or more through rain and snow to eat at little Italy's most "typical" restaurant. Allow the gravelly voiced waitresses to bully you into the mounds of massive lobster stuffed ravioli ( ask for combo Fracomo diavolo house special red / cream sauce- much better delicious) or the mountains of small twisted butterfly pasta smothered in the red lobster-based house sauce Fra diavolo. Pumpkin tortellini!!! Add Garlic bread and a bottle of the cheap wine they stock and you will feast. Large portions make it perfect for sharing.
As mentioned CASH only.
Parking was a bitch.
2. Picco
513 Tremont St
Boston, MA 02116
(617) 927-0066
Categories: Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Pizza
Neighborhood: South End
5 star rating
Their name says it all. It's so much more.
After a miserable experience at Garden of Eden (avoid)
we walked down to Picco
To my dismay (not enough research)-the epiphany: we could have had lunch here instead!
A haven of deliciousness. Crispy crusts that snap with just the right amount of smoky nutty chewy flavor. End the meal with decadent heapings of creamy ice cream and homemade candies and toppings. stand out flavors are coffee-toffee ice cream which kept me up all night and a classic vanilla, raspberry gelatos homemade fudge and nuts on the side for the sundaes. WOW! Friendly and accommodating staff, seated us quickly and adjusted for an extra 2 people including a 3 year old.
Space was modern, w/ long red curtains (perhaps for draft control?)
they make all their own candy that's added to the ice cream. Parking
was easy on sunday@lunch
3. Peach Farm
4 Tyler St
Boston, MA 02111
(617) 482-1116
Category: Chinese
Neighborhood: Chinatown
4 star rating
Mom and auntie Elanor really liked peach farm
The restaurant is cantonese
we had the wau choi- set menu but of course the old chinese ladies of the family had to alter it to be "better"
tofu ground beef and green onion soup
lobster in ginger wine sauce
geoduck clam (avoid-only bad dish of the evening)
pea leaf sprouts w/ garlic (dau miu)
salt and pepper mini pork cutlets (for the cousin who refuses to eat chinese)
beef & hong kong style crispy noodles
seafood fried rice
adzuki red bean soup w/ coconut jelly for dessert
Service was good- caveat: my family speaks cantonese-
dingy and dark interior, grimy walls and battered furniture. typical hole in the wall level of clean. bright notes of fresh seafood- live seafood tanks house your dinner which you watch as the waiter scoops out the still flapping fish. (not for the faint of heart)
4. Jasper White's Summer Shack
149 Alewife Brook Pkwy
Cambridge, MA 02140
(617) 520-9500
Category: Restaurants
Neighborhood: North Cambridge
2 star rating
08/11/2007
As part of my effort to eat all things Bostonian, we attempt Jasper's which is a large cavernous noisy and busy warehouse space. bulk cooked food passes the bar based on freshness and quality. don't expect gourmet food here. very decent seafood selection including oysters shooters & crab legs. typical meal here includes chowder or steamers, followed by crisp and tasty baked lobster with sides of baked beans and boston brown bread (a thick cake-like molasses based bread). gigantic portions cater those who eat a lot. mere mortals should share.
It's expensive for the quality of cooking you get
5. Durgin Park
340 Faneuil Hall Mrkt Pl
Boston, MA 02109
(617) 227-2038
2 star rating
Climb the rickety stairs to the mecca for tourists, where surly waitresses speak with thick accents and slap food down onto the dark wooden tables. Typical dishes include whole lobster with drawn butter and sides of baked beans, corn, Indian pudding typical Boston staple foods. Share your table with other hordes of tourists. A must visit for out-of-towners, a miss for locals would do well to avoid.
6. Legal Seafoods
12 Harborside Dr
Boston, MA 02228
(617) 568-1888
Neighborhood: East Boston
1 star rating
This applies to all the restaurants in this chain, which has not much going on except the freshness of the seafood. boring and repetitious, they ride on the vast ignorance of visiting tourists and indifferent business expense accounts to keep them afloat. Although admittedly better than outposts in Washington DC. Sampled clam chowder, lobster bisque both good flavor but overly thickened with a greasy grainy mouth feel. Tasty lobster roll is the only good thing on the menu, but completely over priced. served with limp coleslaw and soggy fries.
#####
Update- cornmeal crusted softshell crab crunchy and tasty but fiendishly expensive. Fish Fillet staid and boring- served w/ frozen veg mix.
Service was spotty on all occasions. Space was crowded and waitstaff poorly trained and distracted by larger more demanding parties with kids (devil spawn). Long wait for an outrageously expensive meal.
Why have I been more than once? you ask. I admit to family pressure. My cousin likes it there. But never again.
7. Omni Parker House Hotel
60 School Street
Boston, MA 02228
(617) 227-8600
Category: Hotels
Neighborhood: Downtown
1 star rating
Large wedding parties and conventions crowd the old fashioned and dark wood panelled bar and brocaded seats. Avoid if possible, this point of origin for bland and un-appetizing cream pie make this a cocktail stop only. People will always visit, even if they treat you as badly as they treated malcomX and Ho Chi Minh.
8. Mike's Pastry
300 Hanover Street
Boston, MA 02113
(617) 742-3050
Categories: Bakeries, Candy Stores, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Neighborhoods: Charlestown, North End
1 star rating
Packed with clueless tourists ordering "famous" and "typical" canoli and other desserts. with soggy and cardboard like crusts which encase sludgy cement-like sweet cream that tastes overwhelmingly of fake vanilla and leaves a filmy taste in the roof of your mouth.
I would award negative stars if I could
9. Garden of Eden - CLOSED
571 Tremont St
Boston, MA 02118
(617) 247-8377
Categories: Bakeries, American (Traditional)
Neighborhood: South End
1 star rating
Flee the garden from whence came all manner of inedible things. The servers were wroth and we were miserable with leaden souffles and cold scrambles. We needed to order manna from heaven since our minimalist breakfasts came without toast. Our heavy hearts led us to the fantastic ice cream and pizza place down the street. where we will happily abide in milk and honey.
I would give this negative stars if I could